The Trump administration final month deported scores of Venezuelan men to El Salvador, sending them to a maximum-security jail for gang members. The administration claimed that a lot of the males had been members of the Venezuelan gang Tren de Aragua, a bunch that, in line with the executive order decreeing the deportations, is “conducting irregular warfare and enterprise hostile actions towards america.”
Tren de Aragua isn’t invading America. Whereas the analysis group InSight Crime, which has tracked the gang for years, has discovered that it does have a restricted presence in america, researchers have seen no proof that it has organized cells within the nation that cooperate with each other, a lot much less obtain instructions from overseas. The exaggerated authorities claims and ensuing public concern in regards to the group’s actions in america quantity to a basic ethical panic, through which a handful of crimes are cited by politicians as proof of an pressing risk to society.
To make sure, Tren de Aragua is a harmful group, accountable for horrendous crimes in Venezuela and elsewhere in South America. The three of us have spent a long time learning violence in Venezuela exactly as a result of we perceive its capacity to destroy lives, households and neighborhoods. However central to making a safer world is getting the details, causes and options proper. To date, many American politicians, law enforcement officials and journalists have failed to take action, and as an alternative have perpetuated important misconceptions about Tren de Aragua.
The largest false impression considerations the group’s organizational capability. Tren de Aragua was lately designated a terrorist organization by america, alongside way more established teams just like the Mara Salvatrucha in El Salvador and cartels in Mexico. Calling legal teams terrorist is all the time a stretch since they often don’t purpose at altering authorities coverage.
However that is notably the case with Tren de Aragua. In comparison with these others it’s a comparatively younger group with comparatively restricted capability and no historic political aspirations. Certainly, because the Venezuelan military in 2023 stormed the jail that Tren de Aragua managed and was headquartered, the gang has been more and more dispersed, not centrally organized and with no declarations of political targets.
Tren de Aragua emerged within the penitentiary within the city of Tocorón round 2014. Its growth in South America is carefully tied to the mass migration of Venezuelans that accelerated shortly thereafter. Its legal operations primarily contain not worldwide drug trafficking or transnational extortion rackets however migrant smuggling and the sexual exploitation of Venezuelan migrants in Colombia, Chile and Peru. Not one of the group’s major financial actions counsel important growth outdoors of South America.
Though U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers disclosed little about how the boys deported final month had been recognized, we now know that ICE officers use a rubric to assist decide whether or not somebody is a Tren de Aragua member, together with symbols and logos, corresponding to tattoos. The designation of tattoos as a gang identifier presumably stems from the apply of Central American gangs to point membership with tattoos, however our research means that Tren de Aragua, and Venezuelan gangs extra usually, do not need a historical past of doing so. Many younger Venezuelans, like younger folks in every single place, borrow from the worldwide tradition of iconic symbols and get tattoos. That doesn’t imply they’re in a gang.
Organized crime is way much less transportable than folks often suppose. It sometimes includes management of illicit markets, which in flip depends upon relationships with native folks and officers. These networks aren’t simply transferable and restrict mobility. This is likely one of the causes that many legal teams have geography of their title: Sinaloa, Medellín, Cali and, after all, Aragua, an agricultural state in north-central Venezuela, and residential to the Tocorón jail, the place Tren de Aragua originated. These names describe their base of operations and the place the place they’re dominant.
The Trump administration has suggested that Venezuela’s president, Nicolás Maduro, despatched members of Tren de Aragua and different Venezuelan gangs to america to destabilize the nation. However in February, U.S. intelligence companies reportedly circulated findings internally that Tren de Aragua isn’t managed by the Maduro authorities and the gang members who’re in america haven’t been despatched right here by it.
Whereas there may be undoubtedly criminal activity throughout the Maduro regime, its relationship to legal teams quantities to an unstable and volatile collage, with competing armed teams collaborating briefly with the federal government when their various pursuits overlap. The identical holds true with Tren de Aragua: Whereas there have been moments when the group and the Maduro authorities negotiated pacts that served their pursuits, their relationship is finest characterised as antagonistic and aggressive, as evidenced by the military raid on the Tocorón jail.
A handful of news reports about suspected Tren de Aragua members describe them as accountable for severe crimes in America. Arrests have primarily been for crimes like shoplifting, housebreaking and cellphone theft. And naturally different Venezuelan immigrants have additionally dedicated crimes in america; with approximately 770,000 dwelling right here as of 2023, sheer numbers make this an inevitability. None of that is proof of a Tren de Aragua invasion.
Over the previous two centuries the arrival of Irish, Italian, Chinese language and Mexican immigrants in America have produced comparable ethical panics, set off by actual issues but in addition exploited by politicians. Regardless of President Trump’s fixed claims, America isn’t within the grip of against the law wave — preliminary information from the F.B.I. reveals that crime continued to drop final 12 months — and research consistently shows that will increase in immigration don’t trigger will increase in crime.
The Trump administration’s deportations of greater than 200 Venezuelan males to an inhumane and overcrowded Salvadoran jail will virtually definitely assist deter migration, however there are methods to curb immigration that don’t depend on mass criminalization, arbitrary detention and the violation of due course of, all traits of the regime many Venezuelans are attempting to flee.
Reviving dialogue of the bipartisan immigration reform proposal developed in 2023 and 2024 could be a great place to start out. Most everybody concerned within the refugee and immigrant evaluate system agrees that it fails to promptly adjudicate instances and must be strengthened. Interesting proposals by nonprofit organizations — for instance, matching immigrants in communities with labor shortages and facilitating entry to justice providers — must be thought-about. And given that the majority migrants are fleeing poverty and violence of their house nations, extra focus must be placed on bolstering democracy and prosperity south of the border.
None of those initiatives are probably in an administration that appears set on coercive and dissuasive insurance policies. However no matter insurance policies they pursue, immigration officers should respect the rule of regulation and human rights. The mass criminalization, arbitrary detainment and violation of due course of which have characterised the Trump administration’s actions up to now have echoed a few of the ways of the Venezuelan regime many of those younger males presumably fled from. It reduces U.S. credibility and emboldens authoritarians in every single place.
Rebecca Hanson is a professor of sociology on the College of Florida. David Smilde is a professor of sociology at Tulane College. Verónica Zubillaga is a sociologist and co-director of the Community for Activism and Analysis for Coexistence, an anti-violence nongovernmental group in Caracas, Venezuela.
The Instances is dedicated to publishing a diversity of letters to the editor. We’d like to listen to what you concentrate on this or any of our articles. Listed below are some tips. And right here’s our e-mail: letters@nytimes.com.
Comply with the New York Instances Opinion part on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Bluesky, WhatsApp and Threads.
