Michael Rapaport’s shot at Colton Underwood throughout “The Traitors” roundtable didn’t simply land mistaken, nevertheless it detonated your complete vote. Throughout Thursday’s episode, Rapaport went after the previous “Bachelor” lead whereas arguing that Underwood must be suspected as a Traitor, dragging Underwood’s real-life historical past into the sport in a approach that instantly shifted the room. Rapaport claimed Underwood, who got here out as homosexual in April 2021, had an edge at deception as a result of “no person on this room can be higher at holding a secret than you.” Colton Underwood didn’t let it slide.
Article continues under commercial
Michael Rapaport’s Colton Underwood Dig Backfires As Johnny Weir Calls for Solutions
“There it’s. You suppose it was enjoyable for 29 years of my life?” he snapped again, as Rapaport shortly tried to backpedal, insisting his remark had “nothing to do with it.” However Rapaport doubled down on his suspicion, including, “I believe you got here into this sport loving the thought of being a Traitor.”
If Rapaport thought he was making a strategic level, the group clearly didn’t obtain it that approach. Whereas there had been chatter about voting Underwood out, Rapaport’s comment flipped the momentum, and all of the sudden, his identify was the one getting written down.
Article continues under commercial
Olympic determine skater Johnny Weir, who’s overtly homosexual, known as out the implication head-on, “You possibly can’t blame somebody for being compelled right into a closet for almost all of their lives,” Weir mentioned. “That’s what we took it as.” Candiace Dillard Bassett additionally jumped in and requested Rapaport to “make clear” what he meant if he wasn’t making an attempt to mock Underwood’s expertise.
Rapaport, nevertheless, leaned into his argument as an alternative of strolling it again, claiming, “His conduct is of a Traitor. His conduct is secretive. It’s conniving, it’s chirping, it’s commiserating. It’s cowardly.” And when the group pushed again, telling him he was “mistaken” no matter his intentions, Rapaport fired off one other harsh jab, “Take it nevertheless you need. This can be a Traitor. You’re a Traitor, a commiserating and colluding Traitor.”
Article continues under commercial
Rapaport’s Roundtable Blowup Prices Him
BARS on BARS!!!
I performed a tough sport, I performed an actual sport & I had a enjoyable.
By no means needed to offend anybody watching or the solid,Sincerely
The Dopest Smartes Realest to ever stroll within the fort ♥️💚🤍💙💜 pic.twitter.com/T7OTdcZxmr— MichaelRapaport (@MichaelRapaport) January 16, 2026
By the point the votes had been tallied, Rapaport had sealed his personal destiny. He obtained essentially the most votes and was banished, and it wasn’t delicate why. Although the sport is constructed round Faithfuls detecting Traitors, a number of gamers made it clear their votes mirrored how Rapaport dealt with the second.
Even “Survivor” alum Natalie Anderson, who had been pleasant with Rapaport within the sport, mentioned his “holding a secret” assertion was sufficient to alter her vote. “For me, there are some issues that it doesn’t even matter. … Right this moment, the best way you spoke to Colton, for me, it’s sufficient to write down your identify,” she mentioned.
Article continues under commercial
Michael Rapaport Apologizes After Banishing

After his banishment, Rapaport tried to make clear the intent behind his remark, saying, “I meant what I meant inside the context of the sport. It had nothing to do together with his sexuality. I actually sincerely apologize if I offended Colton or anyone in the home. That completely wasn’t the intention.”
He later doubled down on that rationalization in an announcement to TMZ on Friday, saying, “I did converse to [Underwood] proper after filming. We had a fantastic man-to-man dialog, and every thing was very cool and respectful. I like him and want him and his household the very best.”
Article continues under commercial
Followers Drag Rapaport After Colton Underwood Conflict

On-line, viewers lit up Rapaport for the trade and for his general power on the roundtable, with reactions pouring in on X.
One individual wrote, “Why are you at all times yelling?” Others had been far much less forgiving, with feedback together with: “You’re a f-cking piece of sh-t,” and “You f-cking homophobic a-shole”
Not everybody noticed it the identical approach, although. One viewer defended Rapaport’s level as purely gameplay, writing, “I believe Rapaport’s a dope, and even I knew what he meant. It wasn’t about closets, it was in regards to the sport. Cease looking for sufferer factors in different folks’s phrases.”
Colton Underwood’s Coming-Out Phrases Nonetheless Hit Onerous

Underwood, in the meantime, has been open about how troublesome it was to live in the closet, and why lastly saying it out loud felt like survival.
He got here out on “Good Morning America” almost 5 years in the past, telling Robin Roberts, “I’ve ran from myself for a very long time,” including, “I’ve hated myself for a very long time. I got here to phrases with that earlier this 12 months and have been processing it, and the subsequent step in all of this was form of letting folks know.”
“The Traitors” is at present streaming on Peacock.
