The Ghost of Christmas Future appeared to me on a Groups videocall from London.
She was sympathetic however left me petrified of what’s forward for America’s information trade.
Kate Scott-Dawkins, who tracks advert spending for the promoting big WPP Media, stated 2026 will likely be tough for newspapers.
In a forecast launched this month, WPP expects print promoting in U.S. newspapers to plunge 45.3% subsequent yr, to $594 million.
It predicts U.S. newspapers’ digital advert gross sales will develop 1.5%, to $7.2 billion, and complete newspaper promoting to say no 4.7%, to $7.8 billion. That’s after seeing 5.7% progress this yr, to $8.2 billion.
“It’s very tough for native information — it’s very tough for everybody outdoors of the largest, extra nationally targeted papers,” Scott-Dawkins, WPP president of worldwide enterprise intelligence, stated through the interview.
That’s in distinction to progress in promoting in different mediums, together with video video games, social media and digital billboards, massive and small, proliferating open air and in industrial settings.
WPP expects international advert income will develop 8.8% this yr, to $1.14 trillion, and seven.1% in 2026, not counting political advertisements within the U.S.
Greater than $1 billion in promoting is anticipated globally across the World Cup, which will likely be collectively hosted by the U.S., Canada and Mexico.
The forecast was revised upward as a result of the economic system isn’t doing as poorly as anticipated and the AI growth is anticipated to drive extra advert spending, Scott-Dawkins stated.
There are different considerations. Scott-Dawkins famous there’s “bifurcation” with a comparatively small variety of prosperous households accounting for an outsized portion of client spending.
Equally, “a small variety of media proprietor corporations symbolize type of an outsized portion of complete trade advert income, as nicely,” she stated.
WPP tries to help conventional media, recognizing its significance, she stated, however customers more and more get information by issues like AI chatbots as a substitute of newspapers and broadcast TV.
“Regardless of WPP’s ongoing dedication to information and selling these kinds of publishers to shoppers, it’s total an trade in structural decline,” she stated.
State help: That helps makes the case for why authorities ought to assist maintain the native information trade as it really works by its disruption and develops new enterprise fashions.
One strategy is to offer tax breaks. Congress has proposals for this in hand, however is unlikely to approve them anytime quickly.
A handful of states are attempting. The biggest program is about to start in New York, which is finalizing particulars of $30 million worth of refundable tax credits it’s offering per yr over three years.
The cash was budgeted in 2024, however the coverage had glitches needing to be fastened within the 2025 finances. Now it’s going by a rule-making course of and credit, towards 2025 taxes, are anticipated to be obtainable in early 2026.
Newspapers and broadcasters might obtain as much as $25,000 per worker, with credit capped at $300,000 per information group. New York has round 1,100 newspapers.
That’s a strategy to save jobs and papers, nevertheless it isn’t a easy template that different states can use, as a result of every has its personal budgeting course of, famous Zack Richner, a part of a Lengthy Island publishing household that advocated for the credit.
What may very well be replicated is the strategy New York publishers used to create a regionally primarily based advocacy group with skilled lobbyists, he stated.
Richner organized a coalition to help native information and get the longstanding request for tax credits approved.
(Richner, by the best way, additionally expects print newspaper promoting to say no however a lot lower than WPP’s forecast.)
New York additionally benefited from having “an excellent governor” who “understands the position of native information,” stated Diane Kennedy, president of the New York Information Publishers Affiliation.
“Every state’s political dynamics are totally different so it actually relies on who your governor is, who your legislators are, who the management is,” she stated.
Illinois in 2024 permitted a $25 million, five-year-tax credit score program providing as much as $15,000 per journalist and a most of $150,000 per information group per yr.
Washington in 2023 permitted a 10-year enterprise tax exemption for publishers, saving them an estimated $10 million altogether. It was championed by Gov. Bob Ferguson, who was then legal professional basic.
One other proposal, to assist information shops get compensated by tech companies taking advantage of information content material, is being drafted by Washington state Sen. Marko Liias and also will want Ferguson’s help.
Information organizations in these states are fortunate. Federal finances cuts this yr are walloping state budgets, Kennedy famous, so securing tax credit in immediately’s local weather “could be actually tough,” she stated.
Longer-term sustainability: Newspapers should additionally discover methods to get pretty compensated instantly by tech platforms profiting from their work.
To date this has solely been potential for a number of the largest information organizations, and for these in international locations like Australia and France, the place governments compelled tech corporations to barter.
There could also be extra alternatives within the rising AI period. Copyright lawsuits introduced by The New York Instances and others may strengthen publishers’ hand.
Google and Meta are additionally making extra information offers, though that may very well be to keep away from additional lawsuits and antitrust sanctions.
The information trade is concurrently making an attempt to erect stronger fences to guard its materials from on-line poachers.
As a part of that effort, the Native Media Consortium final week introduced a partnership with TollBit, a startup working to assist publishers monitor and monetize AI utilization of their work.
Consortium members function round 5,000 newspapers, radio and TV stations and digital shops within the U.S. and Canada.
CEO Fran Wills stated the partnership will assist information organizations set up TollBit’s software program, giving them a dashboard to see what AI scrapers are accessing their web sites and “get extra intel on what’s happening with their visitors.”
She acknowledged that is solely a primary step towards getting paid by AI platforms. The consortium is speaking to different tech suppliers about extra instruments and will finally assist negotiate fee on behalf of members.
Wills stated exploring and experimenting with these instruments will assist the information trade higher perceive its choices and “which path we wish to collectively go ahead with.”
“The opposite various is to do nothing and let the bots simply proceed to devour our content material with no compensation,” she stated, “which isn’t a sustainable mannequin for any of our publishers.”
Wills is optimistic it’ll work out: “The excellent news is by some means we have now been resilient, for a few of our publishers for over 100 years.”
“It’s actually been a wild trip,” she stated. “Disruption with newspapers began with broadcast TV and radio, after which the web got here alongside, and now AI has come alongside … we’ve discovered learn how to climate these storms, albeit not in addition to we had hoped.”
Certainly, issues might prove higher than anticipated.
I’m inspired by these indicators of progress, unbelievable work by so many journalists throughout 2025 and the help of subscribers and others who worth native information.
Glad holidays and greatest needs for 2026.
