On the night of Wednesday, Might 21, a younger couple was shot to dying exterior the Capital Jewish Museum in Washington, D.C.
Almost everybody shortly and rightly condemned this tragedy. But it’s vital to grasp the character of the assault and what it says about anti-Jewish racism.
Too usually, assaults on Jews are contextualized in a approach that inadvertently blames them for their very own deaths. Some preliminary information reviews famous that the homicide of the couple got here at a time of elevated rigidity in Gaza, as if the continuing conflict ought to present a useful backdrop. Tales that led with the truth that they labored for the Israeli Embassy urged that they might have had it coming.
This phenomenon happens after each assault on a Jewish neighborhood when the attacker doesn’t match the profile of a traditional racist, and when Jews don’t match the mould of helpless sufferer. After a white man murdered 11 aged Jews of their synagogue in Pittsburgh in 2018, the response was unequivocal: Racism and antisemitism are an insupportable stain on our nation.
Elias Rodriguez, charged with first-degree homicide within the taking pictures of Sarah Milgrim and Yaron Lischinsky, is as vile and racist because the Pittsburgh shooter. As Rodriguez was being apprehended by police, he shouted the now acquainted chant, “free, free Palestine.” This phrase, in addition to “globalize the intifada” and “from the river to the ocean” are usually not mere pleas for freedom, however moderately requires violence. We’ve been culturally conditioned to interpret these chants as political speech, however in actual fact they name for the destruction of Israel, which — irrespective of how the chanters could justify it — outcomes ultimately within the destruction of Jewish life.
But Rodriguez will doubtless go down as a deranged actor of political violence who, in some unspecified time in the future, merely misplaced his approach. An activist group he related to, the Party for Socialism and Liberation, which celebrated the Oct. 7 Hamas terrorist assault on Israel and has melded ideologically with the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, has quietly backed away and disavowed him. Self-described socialist teams which have adopted PFLP rhetoric are widespread in Washington state. They had been concerned within the campus encampments and behind the assaults on College of Washington President Ana Mari Cauce’s dwelling. These teams extol violence in opposition to Israel however by no means take duty when their supporters kill Jews.
My first thought once I heard in regards to the homicide of this younger, vibrant couple was, “That would have been me.” After what number of Jewish neighborhood occasions in downtown Seattle have I stepped out onto the sidewalk and into the night time?
Then it hit me: It has occurred right here. It occurred in 2006 when Naveed Haq was “indignant about Israel” and managed to enter the Jewish Federation constructing and shoot six women, killing one. “It may have been me” shouldn’t be an expression in regards to the randomness of the universe. When Jews are attacked, it’s not normally as a result of we’re within the incorrect place on the incorrect time. It really might be us. We’re absolutely conscious of this in all places we go, and whereas we’re devastated over these deaths, we aren’t shocked.
For this reason Jewish establishments the world over have locked doorways, gate codes, guards, safety screenings, steel detectors, bag checks, panic buttons, emergency telephones, “cease the bleed” workshops, safety plans, bulletproof glass, two-way mirrors and the police and FBI on speed-dial.
These protections could mitigate the results of hate. However to counter the results of hate, we have to perceive what hate is.
Rodriguez got down to assault Jews. It doesn’t matter if he was motivated by the Klan or Hamas. It doesn’t matter if he misplaced his approach. The impact is similar. The one distinction is how the story is framed — and the way we reply.
If you want to share your ideas, please submit a Letter to the Editor of not more than 200 phrases to be thought of for publication in our Opinion part. Ship to: letters@seattletimes.com
